Turn your cards into cash or store credit

How To Sell or Trade

Baseball Card Exchange is always buying trading cards, including unopened/factory-sealed hobby and retail boxes and cases, high-end singles and graded cards, authenticated autographs, and common autographs and non-manufacturer relic cards in bulk. View our most wanted buys and start your sale today!


Always know what BBCE is paying for items. If you have a large collection please call Phil @ 219-741-5099 or email him at Phil@bbcexchange.com

Always know what we are paying for items

Payout Options---check, Paypal, or Store Credit

Fast turnaround---Get Paid within 48 hours

check buy list

Ship + sell

Mail your cards to us and we will make you an offer!

Ship your cards to us

Receive an offer

Get Paid within 48 hours!

get started

you come to us

Our store hours are M-F 10a-7p, Saturday 10a-5p, and Sunday 12p-4p! Feel free to call Phil before you come 219-741-5099!

At your convenience

Cash payment

In-person transaction

see location

we come to you

If you want to sell an entire store inventory, a large amount of bulk, or a sizeable collection: Please call Phil at 219-741-5099 to set up a visit!

We take care of the logistics

We do the heavy lifting

In-person transaction

Cash Payment---if requested

Contact Us
  • Rewards

    With every purchase

  • Flash Sales

    Every Friday

  • Always Buying

    Get paid within 48 hours

  • Shipping

    We Ship Internationally

how it works

Selling your cards online has never been easier! Browse our most wanted list to see what we're currently buying and at what price!

Add the items you have for sale, choose how you want to be paid and submit your sale online!

step 1:

submit your order

Check our offer price HERE! Don't see your item? Contact us for a custom quotation for your item or collection.

step 2:

We approve the order

Ship your item within 2 business days. We authenticate, then we ship it to the buyer.

step 3:

pack and send

Make sure to pack safely and securely.

step 4:

We receive and verify, then you get paid!

Get paid within 48 hours!

start selling

meet the buyers

Baseball Card Exchange offers individual sellers and store owners a variety of options to ensure that doing so is as easy and convenient as possible! Be part of us by checking out our Buy List!

  • Phil Endris

    Phil has been collecting sports cards and autographs since he was 7 yrs old. He has a vast knowledge in Sets, Singles (vintage & modern), Unopened Wax (vintage & modern), autographs & memorabilia, and much more. No matter the size of your collection, Phil would love to have a conversation on how BBCE can help sell your collection.

    Call Cell- 219-741-5099 or E-mail phil@bbcexchange.com

visit us

get in touch

Have a question? Give us a call anytime or visit us today!

Baseball Card Exchange

2412 US Highway

41Schererville, IN 46375

(800) 598-8656

(219) 515-6908 (fax)

Sunday 12 PM to 4 PM CST

Mon - Fri 10 AM to 7 PM CST

Saturday 10 AM to 5 PM CST


how long does the authentication process take?

Authentication currently takes about 3-4 weeks to complete!

Order and shipping

We use all new shipping materials when packaging your order to ensure the safest and most secure means in transporting your purchase.

Shipping costs on International Orders do not include and customs clearance, brokerage charges, duties or taxes specific to receiving the order on your end. If you believe there to be any discrepancy or you have any questions, please e-mail us:webstore@bbcexchange.com

how does buy list work?

It's pretty simple, just type in the name of the product into our "buy list" and you will see the our buy price. If that looks good to you add that item to your cart and checkout. Ship to us within two business days and once we receive the item/s you will get paid withing 48 hours!

Click below to start

Buy List